Skip to content

Unexpected behavior of OS X client's close button #97

Open

Description

@pgambling

The close button currently shuts down the application. However, the normal behavior of OS X's close button is to close the window while the application remains active in the dock. Closing the application is accomplished by cmd+q or app menu->quit.

Activity

  1. shaunlebron commented on Feb 17, 2015

    @shaunlebron
    Collaborator

    There are some applications that explicitly close after its last window is closed (e.g. Popcorn Time, System Preferences). Regardless of that, if the window is closed, there's not much else the user can do since our menu only has default items inherited from Atom Shell.

  2. pgambling commented on Feb 17, 2015

    @pgambling
    CollaboratorAuthor

    Wouldn't you still see the dock bounce and notifications even when the
    window is closed?

    On Tue, Feb 17, 2015, 9:51 AM Shaun LeBron notifications@github.com wrote:

    Closed #97 #97.

    —
    Reply to this email directly or view it on GitHub
    #97 (comment).

  3. shaunlebron commented on Feb 17, 2015

    @shaunlebron
    Collaborator

    Not currently. @oakmac, should we re-open the window if the dock icon is clicked?

  4. pgambling commented on Feb 17, 2015

    @pgambling
    CollaboratorAuthor

    I mean IF Cuttle only closed the window and not the application when clicking close, I'd still expect the dock icon the bounce and growl notifications to appear.

  5. oakmac commented on Feb 26, 2015

    @oakmac
    Owner

    I don't know enough about Mac common defaults to have an informed opinion here.

    As a general heuristic, I think we should support the Principle of least astonishment ;)

  6. CASandmann commented on Feb 26, 2015

    @CASandmann
    Collaborator

    In my admittedly limited interactions with OSX, most applications seem to work the way Phil described:

    • If a user closes the application window, the task remains active (the blue light still shows under the icon on the dock)
    • If a notification occurs while the window is closed, the icon will bounce in the tray
    • If the user then clicks the icon, the window reopens
    • Mac users know they can definitively close applications by right-clicking the dock icon and selecting exit
Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

No one assigned

    Labels

    Projects

    No projects

      Milestone

      No milestone

      Relationships

      None yet

      Development

      No branches or pull requests

      Issue actions